Sleep Gummy Reviews

Read Our Review

Sephora Collection x OLLY
Bedtime Beauty

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
Melatonin and L-theanine is an irresistible bedtime combination, but this one takes it up a notch by including Ceramides, little miracle lipids that help protect the skin and retain moisture. Put that gummy to work while you get your well-deserved beauty sleep.
Read Our Full Review!
Olly packs a ton of crowd-pleasing wonders in this gummy, but winds up being a jack-of-all-trades, master of none.
Overall
There's nothing in here we don't love: melatonin, ceramides, l-theanine and lemon balm! But somehow it doesn't add up to the powerhouse sum of its parts we'd expect.
Effectiveness
It sounds so perfect, but ultimately these don't quite deliver as a sleep gummy or as a beauty gummy. These have a small effect, but if you want something more noticeable, we'd spring for a few specific gummies instead of trying to pack it all in one.
Tastiness
Olly, as always, kills it in the flavor department, and these are all plush Plum Berry Blossom goodness.
Bang For Buck
These are definitely an affordable sleep + beauty option, especially if you're just looking for a little beauty routine nightcap.
Get 'em from Sephora
Read Our Review

Natural Vitality
Calm Magnesium Gummies

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
The giant tropical beach on this oversized bottle is a metaphor for the tsunami of ocean-sized CALM that’s about to hit you. We are zealous about magnesium in the Gummy Galaxy, particularly this magnesium lactate! But we cannot refuse any gummy, and we were excited to bring Natural Vitality’s magnesium into our lives. Why magnesium? […]
Read Our Full Review!
Rapid calm and solid dose of magnesium in a sugary sweet gummy. Be forewarned: these are potent, so go easy on 'em!
Overall
Magnesium Citrate infuses your body with immediate calm. Perfect to take before bedtime, and/or making sure your bowels are regular the next day. Our only complaint is how much sugar there is!
Effectiveness
These are astonishingly powerful. Mega calm throughout the body. We find these gummies to be so effective that we only take half the recommended dosage.
Tastiness
This is the drawback for us. They are saccharine sweet and coated unnecessarily in a granular sugar that dominates. Why? Also these are so sticky they feel like they're going to pull your teeth out. Think Jujyfruits.
Bang For Buck
For the incredible potency, these are worth every penny.
Get 'em from Natural Vitality
Read Our Review

Highline Wellness
CBD Night Gummies

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
These are incredible. Probably our favorite offering from Highline Wellness, which offers top-of-the-line quality CBD products all around.
We love pretty much everything they do, but if you’re familiar with the Gummy Galaxy, you know we also love sleeping, possibly more than life itself.
So CBD + melatonin? Sign. Us. Up.
Read Our Full Review!
One of the most potent, flavorful melatonin + CBD gummies to send you off to dreamland
Overall
The Highline Wellness Night Gummy is a dream. It's a vegan gummy created under rigorous testing & quality standards, that also happens to be delicious and potent.
Effectiveness
5 mg of Melatonin in just one gummy is a seriously solid dose. Combine that with either 10 or 20 mg of CBD and it's lights out. (In a good way.)
Tastiness
Flavored with blueberry juice and perfectly crafted into a pillowy square. These are flavor and texture perfection.
Bang For Buck
These aren't the cheapest sleep gummies out there, but they are some of the most affordable sleep gummies that contain CBD. Considering the quality, these are one of our fave gummy deals.
✨ Heads up: the team behind Highline Wellness just launched Reform Wellness: legal delta-8 THC gummies which are pretty amazing. You can read our review here!
Get 'em from Highline Wellness
Read Our Review

Pacifica
Dream Sleep

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
I realize they are vegan, but that shouldn’t be the excuse here for the weird texture. There is a plethora of delicious tasting vegan gummies: these aren’t one of them.
Read Our Full Review!
Read Our Review

SmartyPants
Healthy Immunity Nighttime

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
So we know our way around an immunity gummy in the Gummy Galaxy, and we feel pretty confident when we run our eyeballs down a list of ingredients. From Zicam to Bee Propolis, we’ve done some thorough explorations of what can help keep our immune systems supported. But we got excited when we discovered that […]
Read Our Full Review!
We love this unique Sleep Gummy! Melatonin with Baker's Yeast and Probiotics? Let's do it!
Overall
SmartyPants is a brand we trust highly for quality, vegan, Non-GMO supplements. But this one delivers with some ingredients we hadn't seen before in an immunity gummy: Baker's Yeast & Probiotics, along with your classics like Vitamins C, D and Zinc.
Effectiveness
These are mild on the melatonin. The recommended two gummy dosage delivers just 2mg. But with the extra bit of L-theanine to lull you into slumber, these are a gentle and a great way to get some solid rest while the immunity boosters go to work!
Tastiness
Elderberry is strangely only a flavor here, not an ingredient. But we do love the juicy and tangy Elderberry flavor. Elderberry is the gift that keeps on giving.
Bang For Buck
We wish these were a little cheaper or that they came with a bigger supply. These aren't as affordable as Olly's Immunity Sleep, but they're vegan, high quality and, well, we love them, but they just go too darn quickly.
Shop on Amazon
Read Our Review

OLLY
Immunity Sleep + Elderberry

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
Melatonin, elderberry and echinacea? We can be well-rested and in top-top immune shape? Be still our hearts. We are such fans of all the Olly Sleep gummies, and to fill it with a slew of immune boosters on top of it all (Zinc and Vitamin C, too!) means this one tops our list every time.
Read Our Full Review!
We love a melatonin with benefits, and this plush little nugget comes with all the immunity support we could dream of
Overall
We never realized our sleep gummies were lacking, until we realized that Olly made one chock full of immunity boosters. Our only qualm is we wish these were vegan.
Effectiveness
Melatonin, L-theanine and Lemon got the sleep covered. And Echinacea, Elderberry, Zinc, Vitamin C and Selenium go to work while you do. Whew.
Tastiness
Olly is no slouch in the flavor department and this "Midnight Berry" is no exception. Lush and juicy, you can actually take it before midnight, too, if you're like us.
Bang For Buck
We've said it before and we'll say it again: Olly is all-accessible and affordable. They bring the good stuff to the masses.
Shop on Amazon
Read Our Review

VitaFusion
Melatonin

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
Welcome to another journey into dreamland! This time with Vitafusion’s Melatonin Gummies. Fellow intrepid gummynauts are most likely already familiar with our abiding love for this glorious sleep molecule. We’re perennial fans of SugarBear Sleep and Charlotte’s Web Sleep + CBD. But seeing that our mission is to explore all the gummy vitamins out there, […]
Read Our Full Review!
Effective, delicious, sugar-free*, & totally affordable melatonin gummy from grocery store juggernaut, Vitafusion
Overall
*Well, these do have sucralose. And gelatin, le sigh. But that's about all there isn't to love about these really effective sleep gems.
Effectiveness
Two gummies contain 3 mg of melatonin, and that is our goldilocks sweet spot. But that's not all! They've brought the calming flower power as well: 4.25 mg each of Passion Flower of Chamomile Flower each and 4 mg of Lemon Balm Leaf.
Tastiness
The white peach and green tea is a surprising delicious flavor execution from a brand we didn't have high expectations for. We love this. 🤤
Bang For Buck
Vitafusion is as Box Store Brand as they come. Affordability and accessibility is the name of their game.
Shop on Amazon
Read Our Review

Bach
Rescue Plus Sleep

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
This has a (sweet) strawberry flavor plus the melatonin that we’ve come to expect in a sleep gummy. But these also include some of Bach’s signature flower essences, which is a lovely addition if you’re interested in the subtle effects of homeopathy.
Read Our Full Review!
Great flavor, effective, but are flower essences too woo woo for you you?
Overall
Melatonin with the homeopathic balm of wildflower essences? We're into it. Bach is a brand we love (Rescue Remedy for all!), and we also appreciate that this is vegan.
Effectiveness
2.5 mg of melatonin per gummy plus a plethora of soothing botanicals: Star of Bethlehem, Rock Rose, Cherry Plum, Impatiens, Clematis, and White Chestnut. We are complete.
Tastiness
Not the most original flavor, but this is a bright and fruity strawberry that's not too sweet or cloying. It's a fresh as a Bach wildflower.
Bang For Buck
These are on par with other gummies with comparable melatonin amounts, plus you get the flower power and all the Bach sorcery that comes along with it. A total dream gummy. if you will.
Shop on Amazon
Read Our Review

Nama
Sleep

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
We thought that CBD + Melatonin was the end all be all of blissed out, calgon-take-me-away CBD gummies.
But Nama was all, “hold my beer”, because they just entered the chat with a CBD + Melatonin + CBN gummy! 🤯
Read Our Full Review!
The best sleep gummy we've ever had.
Overall
A potent and generous combo of melatonin, CBD, and CBN that has us melting off into dreamland like magic.
Effectiveness
These hit the dosage sweet spot for every ingredient, bringing deep sleep without any morning grogginess.
Tastiness
While these aren't the most inventive or unique-tasting gummies out there, they're a simple, tasty strawberry, and the inclusion of real fruit earns Nama some bonus points.
Bang For Buck
While not exactly cheap, these are reasonably priced for high-quality CBD + CBN gummies. And we think they're worth every penny, because good sleep is priceless.
Get 'em from Nama
Read Our Review

Not Pot
Sleep CBD Gummies

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
We wager there’s more sleep gummies on this site than any other type of gummy, and that’s because we love ourselves some melatonin, and even devoted an entire blog to pondering its finer qualities. (Honestly, it’s a molecule worth reading about it if you haven’t yet. You definitely want to use it mindfully!) But what’s […]
Read Our Full Review!
Not Pot has crafted the Goldilocks of CBD + melatonin gummies
Overall
While we find Not Pot's aesthetic a bit much & they ignored our emails forever, we can't deny that these are one of the best CBD sleep gummies that we've tried.
Effectiveness
20 mg of CBD + 3 mg of melatonin seems to be our exact sweet spot for sweet dreams without any morning grogginess.
Tastiness
Simple but delicious blueberry with a hint of vegetal hemp. We love the flavor of these.
Bang For Buck
At $35 per bottle, these are similarly priced to brands like Highline Wellness and are one of the more affordable CBD gummy options out there.
Get 'em from Not Pot
Read Our Review

OLLY
Sleep Gummies

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
I wasn’t sure that melatonin even worked having grown accustomed to stronger herbs like Ambien over the years. But these worked like a charm. They also contain a relaxing blend of L-theanine and botanicals like chamomile and lemon balm for extra goodness.
Read Our Full Review!
Olly's botanical-filled Sleep Gummy was our gateway gummy into the melatoninverse, and we never looked back
Overall
We love the ingredient lineup. There's not just melatonin, but also l-theanine, lemon balm, passionflower and chamomile. Your body has no choice but to surrender to the power of the plants. 😴
Effectiveness
These work. We particularly love that these are a straightforward entry point for those new to melatonin. If you're already initiated, Olly's Extra Strength might be a good alternative.
Tastiness
If the idea of Blackberry Zen doesn't have your mouth already watering in anticipation of fruity-filled dreams, we can't help you.
Bang For Buck
Olly is our go-to for effective gummies at affordable prices. Sometimes it seems like these commodity brands at box stores always use gelatin (why??), but for the price, these honestly can't be beat.
Shop on Amazon
Read Our Review

Garden Of Life
Sleep Gummies

Overall
Tastiness
Effectiveness
Bang For Buck
Average
We have an embarrassing confession to make: when we bought these, we thought that they had melatonin in them. 🙈 We were breezing through Target in need of some new sleep gummies, and saw these. We love any and all Garden of Life gummies that have crossed our path thus far, so we just snagged […]
Read Our Full Review!
A non-melatonin sleep gummy?! These are actually surprisingly effective.
Overall
Organic, vegan, herbal sleep gummy? Be still our hearts. Turns out melatonin isn't the only ticket to dreamland.
Effectiveness
We're melatonin junkies, so we weren't sure if these would do much for us. But actually, that Valerian knocks us right out.
Tastiness
Good-enough raspberry flavor: nothing special but nothing terrible either.
Bang For Buck
At $15 for a month's supply, these are definitely affordable. Sleeping well is priceless, anyway.
Get 'em from Target